Market Analysis

Market Carnage

I’ll have a lot more to say on market technicals and macro in the days ahead but I wanted to share a few charts documenting the absolute carnage that markets are in the midst of experiencing and highlight an underlying tragedy weaving through it all.

And please don’t take this as a “I told you so” victory lap, it is far from that. Markets have been extremely challenging in the past few weeks and prices had extended much higher than I and probably even most ardent bulls had expected. So yes, markets had gone against me and it was an arduous exercise, not only from a macro/technical view, but also from a positioning perspective.

Bubbles are the hardest. Reason leaves the building, people get sucked in, and markets appear invincible, people are gloating, bears get relentlessly mocked, and any analysis you put out gets dismissed and one can look incredibly stupid. Not easy.

But that’s the side show, the real tragedy is that you see from an analytical perspective how this will end badly and people will get hurt and so you try to reach as many people as possible to at least warn people and highlight the variant view. Not easy.

And hence I very much appreciated Guy Adami’s kind words today:

And be clear, people just got hurt big time, especially as retail had just jumped hook, line and sinker into the rally. But it’s just a 10% correction, no big deal right, we’ve seen plenty of those before.

No, that’s not the issue, it’s the speed and depth of this rug pull:

The entire rally since the Fed went hog wild with liquidity in October was taken out in a matter of days. Just last week we had all time highs. Now $DJIA is below the July and September highs and at the October lows.

Which sends an ominous message: Unless buyers sold all are under water. And don’t tell me everybody sold the top. There are a lot of trapped buyers above. Four months worth of buying taken out.

THIS is why I kept warning (examples see What if, Distortion, Never go Full Retard, Chipping Away), that these liquidity runs are dangerous, they entice people to FOMO chase stocks into ungodly valuations and then they get hurt. That’s what happened in 2000, that’s what happened in 2007 and the may have just happened now.

You know it may actually be true that such valuations may not be sustainable:

And so the end destination was visible technically even in January:

We know what happened. Warnings were ignored, markets went on to make even further highs and markets even more dangerous, but now, after $VIX retested its breakout, markets have reached the same destination:

And the carnage is deep, and late 2019 and early 2020 buyers got spanked badly:

And now markets are engaged in a  key battle for control:

I’ll address the implications in more detail this weekend and I’ve been documenting the current technical journey a bit in the thread below this tweet:

But for now I want to finish off with highlighting the real tragedy here in all this and that is that the real message will likely get lost in all this. Most likely the popular narrative will be to blame the coronavirus as the unforeseen event, nobody could have seen this coming, this was not something anyone could have prepared for.

While that’s true on the surface it completely misses the larger point: The Fed, with it liquidity operations masked all the underlying issues in the markets over the past year. We had no earnings growth in 2019, we had multiple expansion. The bond market never confirmed the reflation trade, Gold had been rallying for months signaling something was amiss. And now the Fed left itself vulnerable to not being able to deal with a real crisis and basically openly invited people to TINA chase stocks into high valuations.

The Fed gave no warning to investors, instead it cheerlead investors off the cliff. Even last week Fed officials defended valuations and saw nothing wrong with anything adding to the atmosphere of complacency.

And now everyone will blame the virus, but not the reckless chase into stocks into historic valuations to begin with.

Which is unfortunate, because that’s the real lesson, a lesson that was already learned the hard way in 2000, but many participants are now at risk of learning again:

For now we remain in the midst of a nasty correction. There will be rally opportunities and we see some of this already in the intra-day action. But be clear now: This is a major battle for control and major technical damage has been inflicted on this market. The next few weeks and months will be a complex journey. Volatility is back for now, and complacency has evaporated. Market carnage tends to do that.

For the latest public analysis please visit NorthmanTrader. To subscribe to our market products please visit Services.

All content is provided as information only and should not be taken as investment or trading advice. Any investments, trades, and/or speculations made in light of the ideas, opinions, and/or forecasts, expressed or implied herein, are committed at your own risk, financial or otherwise. For further details please refer to the disclaimer.

Categories: Market Analysis

13 replies »

  1. Sven, sounds like “I told you so” to me… and you are right to say it, 100%. Credit where credit’s due! For someone who follows your blog on a daily basis, I was warned and prepared. Thank you!

  2. Thank you. Butt liquidity injections have not stopped….so the narrative that liquidity injections automatically lead to higher stock prices don’t seem to hold.

    • I think, having read Sven’s analyses, that the liquidity injections were able to lift stock valuations in a specific scenario – in a low volume environment, in overnight, pre-market hours, via the gap-ups – as Sven had previously pointed out in many articles.
      It appears that liquidity injections can be overwhelmed during daytime market hours with high volume participation; the liquidity injections are not sufficiently powerful to overwhelm an ocean tsunami of sellers…

  3. You were right that the markets were very over brought but it took the coronavirus to shake the exuberance.

  4. The troops were lined up in front of SPX 3000; much blood was spilled and the battle was lost. Mayhap there’ll be an emergency Fed cut tomorrow unless there’s a market improvement overnight, but I doubt that would have any lasting effect – just a waste of bullets for an audience of one.

    It will be a while before COVID-19’s initial effects are seen in economic statistics, and a while before we can glimpse how the virus’s spread is likely to roll out. Thus it’ll be a long while before a true bottom in markets comes into view.

    At least he’ll be able to blame the virus for ruining the wonderful and MAGAful world he created. /s

  5. I am failed trader: in january 2018 I thought we had seen the top….went to aggressive on the short side….but survived ….and then October 2018 I really thought it was THE TOP…..december 2019 I felt like a hero….I did expect a bounce….but could not believe my eyes when we crossed 25 K…..and bailed out at 26 K….I tried one more big short in June 2019….but I had to suffer again big losses…since then, I simply have lost the gutts to short this market. I lost a very large piece of my kapital.

    • 2 things that you always have to keep in mind on the markets:
      “The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent”
      “In economics, things take longer to happen than you think they will, and then they happen faster than you thought they could.”

    • Bro, check out the bear blogs….almost all of them are dead!

      This bull market has suckered in a lot of bears.

      Heed Rick’s words below in the future my friend!

  6. You are the messiah telling the truth. The ws fraudsters and annalysts are herd runners. I really appreciate all your work. This is great.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.