Retail investors are worshipping at the altar of FOMO (fear of missing out). It may prove to be a painful experience.
Never before has retail gotten this aggressively exposed to stocks. Just in time when central banks and buybacks are pulling back. I talked a bit about this in the recent The Carrot Top, but I want to expand a bit on this to issue a general warning for retail: The boat is fully loaded in one direction. Be aware.
Wall Street will not warn retail, they’ll keep pushing the envelope until the very bitter end. It’s actually quite easy to be a bull. Keep raising targets, always be optimistic, and when something breaks shrug your shoulders and say: Hey what are you gonna do? Stuff happens. The Fed will come to the rescue.
And the cycle begins anew.
You know the drill:
Just remember, Wall Street will never tell you to sell.#2008forecasts pic.twitter.com/c664pSO1No
— Sven Henrich (@NorthmanTrader) July 14, 2017
Remember the primary job of Wall Street is to get retail to invest, and to be fair, they are doing a fabulous job.
And so every December we see the same annual ritual. Here’s the message sent to retail, we can only go higher. $SPX targets for 2018:
Here’s a visual from BAML:
The primary argument: Wall Street is not yet euphoric:
Really? What’s this:
$DJIA futures weekly RSI 86.78.
Pedal to the metal till it melts. pic.twitter.com/NYLFODHht7
— Sven Henrich (@NorthmanTrader) December 4, 2017
Not euphoric? Let’s dig in a bit deeper into the data.
You may have seen my Rydex chart indicating record bullish allocations in The Carrot Top:
Last night Jesse Felder sent me some more data points confirming the same:
The American Association of Individual Investors’ asset-allocation poll shows members’ exposure to stocks are as heavy as it was near the 2000 peak. Cash allocations fell 1.2 percentage points to 13.9%. Cash allocations were last lower in December 1999 (12.0%).
TD Ameritrade’s Investor Movement Index of retail activity “saw its largest single-month increase ever in November, increasing over 15% to hit an all-time high of 8.53. TD Ameritrade clients were net buyers for the tenth consecutive month.”
Combine it with sentiment:
“52 percent said they believed the stock market could sustain continued growth for five years without a downturn of 10 percent or more.”
It’s actually the perfectly logical conclusion of what central bank interventions have wrought:
The BOJ balance sheet is now at 121% of GDP the ECB’s at 41% of GDP.
The result of course is we haven’t corrected at all. We are now in the longest market period without even a 5% correction. Ever:
We haven’t had a single down month in 2017 which historically has never happened either:
And the rush into long equity funds has been unprecedented:
Get us into stocks. We can’t go down, we can only go up. FOMO.
So when I say central banks have created a monster I really mean it.
And so it’s no surprise that central bank policy is viewed by some as the greatest risk to asset prices in 2018:
“The biggest risk to asset prices and the global economy would be if the biggest institutions reduce their monetary stimulus at the same time. Rather than reflecting the prospects of individual institutions, the greatest monetary policy uncertainty facing the global economy is what would happen if all these central banks, along with the People’s Bank of China, were to decide to reduce their monetary stimulus at the same time. When it comes to central banks, this is the biggest source of risk to asset prices and the global economy, and it would call for high-frequency policy monitoring and close international consultations.”
Asset prices are a central bank planned construct that has resulted in retail being completely long and fully exposed to equities.
And I have not even addressed the trillions of dollars exposure all being long short $VIX products:
BAML has a phrase for this: “Yield starvation forces selling volatility for yield”. “Forces” being the operative word:
Note the center piece: “Unprecedented central bank policy & low growth recovery”.
By the way I’m not picking on BAML here, not at all.
But I’m highlighting that 2017 has seen an unprecedented rush by retail into the most highly valued stock market since 1900 according to Goldman, a market that remains entirely uncorrected.
But nobody is issuing any risk warnings here. Keep going long my friends we can only go higher and if there’s a dip buy it. And no doubt this strategy has worked.
My perspective remains a variant one: This singularly oriented market construct is at extreme high risk that some trigger will pop all of this.
In a world where nothing has mattered and corrections have disappeared altogether it may be a fair question to ask what such a trigger may be. I’ll leave that for a future post, but I will say this: Triggers are often the excuse to assign cause after the fact. But it is the construct itself that seeds the depth of the ultimate unwind.
Worshippers at the altar of FOMO have come accustomed to no dip ever lasting. Will they find themselves slow to react when one does?
For our market products please visit Services.
All content is provided as information only and should not be taken as investment or trading advice. Any investments, trades, and/or speculations made in light of the ideas, opinions, and/or forecasts, expressed or implied herein, are committed at your own risk, financial or otherwise. For further details please refer to the disclaimer.
Categories: Market Analysis
Yes, everyone (and I mean EVERYONE) is selling vol. When VIX eventually breaks through the carnage will be sudden and absolutely epic. Got popcorn?
Hi Northie, been a fan of your work for a long time. I agree with the analysis (on every single article that you post). I just always remain curious .. what’s going to bring us back to reality? There have been so many macro events that in any normal time would have led to healthy pullbacks, true price discovery etc.
C.Bank interventions or divine interventions … be that as it may, timeframe to handle such a VIX explosion or market correction is critical to truly appreciate the ‘correctness’ of this really awesome analysis and profit from the same.
If, and it is a big IF, we ever get a 5% correction (I lived through the dot com boom-bust and am old enough to remember them…), I suspect the VIX will be at 30. The BTC traders and nuevo trading experts have probably not seen anything like it. Thoughts on the same?
Thanks for the amazing work you do and share with us so generously.
Great article! Thanks! There are (still) a few (rational) analysts such as yourself that can see where this is headed, however, it’s still “party on” mode as per Chuck Prince’s now infamous quote.
“When the music stops, in terms of liquidity, things will be complicated. But as long as the music is playing, you’ve got to get up and dance. We’re still dancing.” – Chuck Prince, former chairman and CEO of Citigroup (told to the Financial Times on July 10, 2007).
FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out) corollary: TINA (There Is No Alternative). 🙂
steph pomboy @spomboy
steph pomboy Retweeted Jesse Felder
6:27 AM – 16 Nov 2017
“As i’ve been calling it: it’s a harvey weinstein market. Old, bloated but if you don’t snuggle up to it ill cost you your career–until one day, for no apparent reason, its egregious transgressions finally matter”
“Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” – Albert Einstein (misattributed) – Narcotics Anonymous
“The four most dangerous words in investing are: ‘this time it’s different.'” – Sir John Templeton
Navigating the Speculative Id of Wall Street
John P. Hussman, Ph.D.
Dec. 04, 2017
“Illusions commend themselves to us because they save us pain and allow us to enjoy pleasure instead. We must therefore accept it without complaint when they sometimes collide with a bit of reality against which they are dashed to pieces.”
– Sigmund Freud
The fleecing of retail by the sell side. Will it be different this time (rhetorical)?
There’s nothing wrong with cash. It gives you time to think. – Robert Prechter, Jr.